“What are you thinking?”, Lyra saw that Hermione was deep in thought.
“I remembered my stupid activism at school, that S.P.E.W. idea about fighting about the rights of House Elves by trying to liberate them by trickery and propaganda, which ended up with all of them disliking and avoiding me, and I interpreted it as them having internalised their oppression so profoundly that they can’t even imagine their lives without it. It’s a typical Marxist and Feminist thing – they just make assumptions and then force things upon people. I never bothered to ask them what they wanted, and yet, that is always the first thing you and Harry do. You ask people and other beings what they want, and then work with them. You saw how Harry approached the Centaurs – he greeted them respectfully, introduced us, told them our intentions outright, and asked for their permission. They loved it. I just generalised House Elves from the example of Dobby, who actually wanted to be free because he was treated badly. I never bothered to revise my opinion when I saw Winky, the girl Elf from the Crouch family, who was given clothes by her patriarch because she allowed his Death Eater son to escape. Winky was devastated and inconsolable over it and even started drinking. But that’s the thing – with my neo-Marxist upbringing, I saw only confirmations of my theories everywhere, never rebuttals. I would see a miserable housewife and saw her as a confirmation of my feminist ideas, but I would never perceive hundreds of happy housewives like ourselves, or I would dismiss their happiness as internalised oppression or some other stupid nonsense. It’s a horrible ideology that tramples over people’s desires and freedoms because you assume you’re smarter, better, more educated, more ‘enlightened’. And you’re not; you’re just arrogant, conceited, disrespectful and dismissive of others. You don’t see people, you see categories and classes”, she was all riled up.
“It sounds very much like the Death Eater ideology with some sugar coating”, Lyra mused. “They, too, don’t see people; only what they symbolise in their ideology. They are either useful or obstacles. Voldemort never actually cared about people, and this feminism thing looks like it doesn’t actually care for women, only what they are supposed to be in their ideology”.
“That’s exactly right”, Hermione nodded. “Can you believe that the feminists would try to liberate the two of us from our oppression? Yes, I know, it’s completely absurd, but their entire thinking is absurd. They would say that we internalised patriarchal oppression and we should show independence by, I don’t know, annoying our husbands and making their lives miserable or something”.
Lyra thought about it. “The underlying assumption seems to be that love and service are inherently demeaning, and argumentative abrasiveness is emancipating?”
“Apparently”, Hermione agreed. “It seems that the thought that you would want to do nice things for someone you love never crossed their minds, because they know as much about love as Voldemort did”, she snickered.
“Yes, he also didn’t know what love was all about, and he thought service was about submission to him out of fear or something”.
“The feminists are exactly like that”, Hermione nodded. “They don’t understand love, only transactions based on power, and loving service, in their eyes, is a sign of oppression and subjugation, and love is self-deceit whose function is to dress up the subjugation into something palatable”.
“And you say that kind of thinking is actually common among the muggles?”, Lyra was astounded.
“It used to be just a few crazy women with lonely, hateful, pathetic lives, who were laughed at by everybody, but then they started making it part of the general education and by now more-less everybody is like that, and they are brow-beating the dissenters into submission”, Hermione shrugged. “If you say you’re not a feminist they ask you why you hate women and want them to be slaves or something”.
“Wouldn’t they realise that women would actually want to be like you and me?”
“They don’t ask women anything. They assume they know better, the way I assumed I know better what House Elves need, and when they tried to argue I would dismiss their opinions as internalised oppression and tried to force my will upon them, of course for their benefit. And then I saw Harry treat Kreacher kindly, like a cherished family member, giving him the medallion Regulus left in that cave, and that single act did more than all my stupid and misguided activism. He just treated Kreacher like a person and trusted him. Feminists and other activists never trust people to know what’s best for them. They just assume that they are more educated, more aware, that they are reading the situation correctly with their ideological playbook. They would implicitly consider us stupid and unaware, simply because we didn’t look at reality and come to the conclusions they see as the only right ones”, Hermione shrugged. “My stupid teenage self would try to convince Colette to accept freedom, and I would have just offended and alienated her, since she sees herself as part of our House, she’s proud of its greatness and magic, and wants to do her part to assure that it thrives. Being ‘free’, to her, means being thrown out and abandoned by your own family, being homeless, unloved, deprived of the ancient greatness you used to be a part of. It would be a terrible thing to do to someone. It would be as if someone tried to ‘free’ the two of us from our husbands and children, and be surprised when we would rather die, explaining it with internalised oppression”.
Lyra thought about it in silence. “I may see an instance of this kind of thinking – the Statute of Secrecy, separating us from the Muggles. Nobody was actually asked about it. They merely enacted it, and now their civilization is diving straight into materialistic madness, feminism and other crazy ideologies, and we are deprived of all the good and interesting things they discovered in the mean time”, she nodded. “It might be imprudent to consider rescinding it, especially considering the ideological contamination that might come from them, considering all that you’ve told me, but at least we could make some gradual efforts”.
“What do you mean?”
“I’m not sure. Intuitively, some cooperation seems prudent since the Ministry is more-less broke all the time, and additional taxation of our small and stressed population seems like a bad idea. How about legalising some trade, of course in ways that would maintain secrecy, but create some kind of an increased economic flow that would be taxable, allowing the Ministry to finance itself?”, Lyra put her index finger to her lips, thinking.
“Tax on added value”, Hermione helped. “The muggles have that. Basically, tax all commercial transactions to a fixed rate”.
“How much would that be?” Lyra perked up.
“From 15 to 25%, I guess, depending on how greedy and desperate a country is”, Hermione smiled.
“We’re desperate, but let’s start with 10% in order not to scare people too much and make it easy to calculate”, Lyra suggested. “Make front companies in the Muggle world connected with companies here, to anonymise all transactions. Trade only in non-magical goods, convert muggle money into gold on their side, convert gold into galleons here, let Gringotts get a share of that”.
“You have very mature ideas about this for someone who just thought of it”, Hermione looked at her sister suspiciously.
“Who says I just thought of it?”, Lyra winked. “I’m describing what my father has been doing for decades. I’m just considering legalising it”.
“Oh!”, Hermione looked at her with her mouth open. “So that’s where those Spanish and Italian hams and fancy cheese have been coming from”.
“But of course”, Lyra beamed. “We are selling agricultural products from our estate wholesale, to a muggle retail chain, through an intermediary. The price they owe us is put on a ledger. Then we order fancy things from their catalog for our own needs and it’s deducted from the ledger. The payout is monthly, and we have a bank account there, for our proxy. We also lease land and buildings to muggles, and money from that also goes to the proxy account. Periodically, we buy gold bars, and we sell them to the Goblins for Galleons, and they get a cut from that, of course. Almost nothing in the whole chain is illegal, strictly speaking, but the whole concept is illegal under the Statute of Secrecy so dad has to bribe the right people to look the other way, and the bribe money, of course, comes from that income stream; you don’t really think he’s been dipping into our Gringotts vault for that, do you?”, she smiled mischievously.
“You, my most cherished Lady, would make a great Ferengi”, Hermione winked. “Remind me never to play Tongo with you, because you would evade and confront your way to Total Monopoly in your first game”.
Lyra looked at her with complete confusion.
“It’s something from a Muggle fictional TV show, that takes place in the future on some space station where humans meet aliens, and the Ferengi are the alien species very much like our Goblins, only with bigger ears, and more thirst for profit. They have their philosophy centred around the so called Rules of Acquisition that explain how to monetise everything, and Tongo is a game they are playing for entertainment, and, of course, money”, she explained.
“I don’t have ears that big. Do I?”, Lyra checked, and Hermione broke into laughter.